OpenStack Nova V.S. Eucalyptus Feature Comparison

This page attempts to enumerate how Nova and 
Eucalyptus compare

Current Status2011-05-23

The latest one click OpenStack Compare

In this topic , administrator should know about features in OpenStack NOVA 


Feature
Eucalyptus
Nova

EC2 Query API
(./)
(./)

EC2 Soap API
(./)
{X}

OpenStack API (/ Rackspace API)
{X}
(./)

Secure communication
between components
(./)
{X}

Trivial horizontal
scalability for all
components
{X}
(./)

Built in web admin console
(./)
{X}

Command line interface for managing users
(./)
(./)


Amazon EC2 API completeness

Note: Info on Eucalyptus was provided entirely by grep. Please don't hesitate to correct errors.
EC2 API method
Eucalyptus
Nova

AllocateAddress
(./)
(./)

AssociateAddress
(./)
(./)

AttachVolume
(./)
(./)

AuthorizeSecurityGroupIngress
(./)
(./)

BundleInstance
{X}
{X}

CancelBundleTask
{X}
{X}

CancelSpotInstanceRequests
{X}
{X}

ConfirmProductInstance
{X}
{X}

CreateImage
{X}
{X}

CreateKeyPair
(./)
(./)

CreatePlacementGroup
{X}
{X}

CreateSecurityGroup
(./)
(./)

CreateSnapshot
(./)
{X}

CreateSpotDatafeedSubscription
{X}
{X}

CreateTags
{X}
{X}

CreateVolume
(./)
(./)

DeleteKeyPair
(./)
(./)

DeletePlacementGroup
{X}
{X}

DeleteSecurityGroup
(./)
(./)

DeleteSnapshot
(./)
(./)

DeleteSpotDatafeedSubscription
{X}
{X}

DeleteTags
{X}
{X}

DeleteVolume
(./)
(./)

DeregisterImage
(./)
(./)

DescribeAddresses
(./)
(./)

DescribeAvailabilityZones
(./)
(./)

DescribeBundleTasks
{X}
{X}

DescribeImageAttribute
(./)
(./)

DescribeImages
(./)
(./)

DescribeInstanceAttribute
{X}
{X}

DescribeInstances
(./)
(./)

DescribeKeyPairs
(./)
(./)

DescribePlacementGroups
{X}
{X}

DescribeRegions
(./)
(./)

DescribeReservedInstances
{X}
{X}

DescribeReservedInstancesOfferings
{X}
{X}

DescribeSecurityGroups
(./)
(./)

DescribeSnapshotAttribute
{X}
{X}

DescribeSnapshots
(./)
{X}

DescribeSpotDatafeedSubscription
{X}
{X}

DescribeSpotInstanceRequests
{X}
{X}

DescribeSpotPriceHistory
{X}
{X}

DescribeTags
{X}
{X}

DescribeVolumes
(./)
(./)

DetachVolume
(./)
(./)

DisassociateAddress
(./)
(./)

GetConsoleOutput
(./)
(./)

GetPasswordData
{X}
{X}

ImportKeyPair
{X}
{X}

ModifyImageAttribute
(./)
(./)

ModifyInstanceAttribute
{X}
{X}

ModifySnapshotAttribute
{X}
{X}

MonitorInstances
{X}
{X}

PurchaseReservedInstancesOffering
{X}
{X}

RebootInstances
(./)
(./)

RegisterImage
(./)
(./)

ReleaseAddress
(./)
(./)

RequestSpotInstances
{X}
{X}

ResetImageAttribute
(./)
{X}

ResetInstanceAttribute
{X}
{X}

ResetSnapshotAttribute
{X}
{X}

RevokeSecurityGroupIngress
(./)
(./)

RunInstances
(./)
(./)

StartInstances
{X}
{X}

StopInstances
{X}
{X}

TerminateInstances
(./)
(./)

UnmonitorInstances
{X}
{X}




EC2 features

EC2 feature
Eucalyptus
Nova

Shared AMIs
(./)
(./)

Parameterized launch (user-data)
(./)
(./)

Instance metadata
(./)
(./)

Public AMI's
(./)
(./)

Reboot instance
(./)
(./)

Retrieve console output
(./)
(./)

Paid AMI's
{X}
{X}

Multiple instance types
(./)
(./)

Instance launch time
(./)
(./)

Elastic IP's
(./)
(./)

Availability zones
(./)
(./)

User selectable kernels
(./)
(./)

Elastic Block Store
(./)
(./)

Booting without a ramdisk
(./)
(./)

Windows Support
{X}
(./)

Reserved Instances
{X}
{X}

Auto Scaling
{X}
{X}

Elastic Load Balancing
{X}
{X}

CloudWatch
{X}
{X}

Virtual Private Cloud (IPSec)
{X}
{X}

Shared snaphsots
{X}
{X}

AMI's backed by EBS
{X}
{X}

Spot Instances
{X}
{X}

Sticky session sin Elastic LB
{X}
{X}

cc1.4xlarge
{X}
{X}

Specify IP address for inst in VPC
{X}
{X}

Tags
{X}
{X}

Filters
{X}
{X}

Idempotent RunInstance calls
{X}
{X}

Import keypair
{X}
(./)

SSL termination
{X}
{X}

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The method of Web Service HA+LB in OPENSTACK NOVA for private cloud only

Image
Cloud Server HA+LB  in NOVA


Our purpose is to provide uninterrupted   web services  with low cost in OPENSTACK. Due to all instances traffic through Nova-Network host in a basic deployment of NOVA . And it's hard to do HA+LB for Nova-Network. As I know it will be very hard to implement. 
After read "Bootstrapping OpenStack Clouds" doc writed by DELL....The fault zone concept it much easier and cheaper. 



There're three diagrams ....
I.Two zones topology , share nothing between each zones. But combine two instance network in same network segment. Zone1 using 192.168.1.0/25,   Zone2 using 192.168.1.128/25 . We do  not using floating ip. Let instance route from Core Network  Switch directly.




Read more